November 20, 2026 8 min read
Maca or ashwagandha: which root actually belongs in your routine? I get this question at the warehouse more than almost any other root query, and the honest answer is that they suit different tastes and routines rather than compete for the same spot.

Maca (Lepidium meyenii) is a Peruvian tuber with a malty, nutty flavour that people typically reach for in the morning. Ashwagandha (Withania somnifera) is an Ayurvedic root with an earthy, bitter edge, more often taken in the evening.
Both are filed under "adaptogen," a term borrowed from mid-20th-century pharmacology rather than a recognised medical category. This guide compares how each tastes, how each has traditionally been used, and how to actually get either into a cup without gagging on the bitterness. It is not medical advice: if you take regular medication, talk to your doctor before adding either root.
Maca and ashwagandha are unrelated plants from opposite sides of the world, grouped together mostly because both carry the informal "adaptogen" label. Maca is a cruciferous root grown at extreme altitude in the Peruvian Andes. Ashwagandha is a nightshade-family shrub root cultivated across India and parts of the Middle East. Their chemistry, traditional use, and flavour have little in common beyond that shared marketing category.
Maca belongs to the Brassica family, the same botanical group as broccoli, cabbage, and radish. It grows at 3,800 to 4,500 metres in Peru's central highlands, notably the Junín region, where cold nights, intense sun, and thin air create genuinely harsh growing conditions. It has been part of the Andean diet for well over 2,000 years, traditionally ground into flour, boiled, or fermented into a drink called chicha de maca.
It is closer to a starchy root vegetable than a conventional herb: about 59% carbohydrate, 10% protein, and 8% fibre by dry weight.
Ashwagandha sits in the Solanaceae family, related to tomato, potato, and pepper rather than to true ginseng, despite the "Indian ginseng" nickname it sometimes carries. It grows in the drier regions of India, particularly Madhya Pradesh and Rajasthan, and has held a central place in Ayurvedic practice for thousands of years, where it is classed as a rasayana, a traditional category of tonic herbs.
The word "adaptogen" itself is a 20th-century pharmacological term, coined by Soviet researcher Nikolai Lazarev in 1947 and later formalized by pharmacologist Israel Brekhman. It is a loose label for roots and herbs, with no specific, targeted definition. It is not an approved regulatory health category in the EU or US, so I treat it here as traditional and marketing shorthand rather than a claim. What follows is a practical comparison of taste, traditional use, and preparation, not a verdict on which root is "better."
Maca tastes malty and nutty, with a faint butterscotch sweetness that most people find easy to like. Ashwagandha tastes earthy and distinctly bitter, closer to raw cacao nib than to anything most tea drinkers are used to. Both are almost always taken as a powder stirred into a drink rather than steeped loose like tea leaves.
Maca comes in raw and gelatinized forms. Gelatinized maca has been heated and pressure-processed to remove some of its starch content; it dissolves more easily and tastes milder than raw powder, and despite the name it has nothing to do with animal gelatine. Colour varies too: yellow maca is the most common and mildest, red is often a touch sweeter, and black tends to be the most assertive. The powder itself is usually cream to light brown regardless of the raw root's original colour.
Ashwagandha's bitterness comes from withanolides, the steroidal compounds researchers study most closely in the plant, and it is genuinely more of an acquired taste than maca. In my experience running a root tea range, customers trying ashwagandha for the first time are far more likely to ask how to mask the flavour than customers trying maca.
Cocoa, cinnamon, cardamom, and warm milk all help; some people simply stir in a spoon of honey or a chopped date.
Both roots are increasingly sold pre-blended into lattes and drink mixes, often combined with cacao, cinnamon, or vanilla to round out the flavour before it ever reaches your cup. Buying loose powder instead of a pre-mixed blend gives you more control over strength and a lower price per serving, at the cost of doing the flavour-balancing yourself.
One common mistake: dropping either powder straight into a cold liquid. Both clump on the surface rather than dissolving. Make a small paste with a splash of hot water or warm milk first, then top up the rest of the drink.
Maca has been part of the Andean diet for centuries, traditionally eaten as a staple food and, according to folklore, eaten in the region's punishing altitude and cold. Ashwagandha has been used in Ayurvedic practice for thousands of years as a rasayana, a category of tonic herbs in Ayurvedic practice. This is not medical advice.
Classical Ayurvedic texts often describe ashwagandha root boiled in milk or ghee before being taken, a preparation echoed in the modern "moon milk" trend. Maca, similarly, was traditionally cooked rather than eaten raw, most often boiled into a porridge or baked into flatbread, since the raw root is fibrous and not especially palatable on its own.
Maca's natural sterols and compounds called macamides are among the plant chemistry people mention most, though it is the malty flavour that most customers notice first.
As of now, maca does not carry an approved EFSA health claim in the EU, so we describe it here in terms of where it grows and how it is eaten.
Ashwagandha is also sold as standardized root extracts such as KSM-66, usually in capsules, and these are very different products from the raw root powder.
It is worth being precise here: extract doses describe a concentrated product, not a spoonful of raw root powder stirred into milk. Extracts are typically several times more concentrated than the whole powder, so a capsule dose does not translate into "drink two cups a day" advice for tea-style preparations. Ashwagandha also has no approved EFSA health claim in the EU at present.
The choice usually comes down to timing and taste rather than one root outperforming the other. Maca's malty sweetness suits a morning smoothie or a coffee alternative. Ashwagandha's earthy profile is more often taken in the evening. Some people alternate between the two, or use them for different goals, ideally with a healthcare professional's input if they take any regular medication.
Morning use of maca tends to pair with the same routines as a coffee substitute: blended into a smoothie, stirred into oat milk, or added to porridge before a workout, echoing its traditional role as a staple food. Evening use of ashwagandha often shows up as part of a "moon milk" style drink: warm milk, a pinch of cinnamon, and a small measure of the powder before bed. Neither timing is a hard rule: some people prefer ashwagandha earlier in the day if bitterness bothers them less on an empty stomach, and others use maca in the afternoon as an afternoon drink instead of a second coffee.
We stock both, along with over 30 other root products, and I would not tell a customer which one is "better." I ask what time of day they are trying to solve for, and what flavour they can tolerate. Some people rotate between the two through the week rather than committing to one; there is no rule that you must pick one, and it is a common personal preference.
If you take regular prescription medication of any kind, speak to your doctor before adding either root, and especially before combining them; neither has been studied for interactions with prescription drugs as thoroughly as you might expect.
Both maca and ashwagandha work best stirred into a warm base rather than steeped like loose-leaf tea. A milk-based drink, a mellow rooibos, or a spiced chai all soften the earthiness and give the powder something to bind to instead of clumping on the surface.
A simple method: mix half a teaspoon of powder with a splash of hot water or milk to form a smooth paste, then stir that into 200 to 250 ml of your chosen base. Adjust the amount up gradually over several days rather than starting with a full tablespoon, both to gauge how you feel about the taste and to stay within the amount recommended on the product label.
Rooibos is a good base for maca: it is naturally caffeine-free and slightly sweet, so it does not fight the malt notes. A cardamom-and-ginger chai base works well for ashwagandha, since the spice mix carries enough character to cover the bitterness. For a sweeter pairing, a small measure of maca works well stirred into a vanilla rooibos, while ashwagandha pairs naturally with darker, spicier bases like a masala chai or a cacao-forward hot chocolate, where the cocoa's own bitterness hides it.
Unlike our green and black teas made from Camellia sinensis, neither maca nor ashwagandha naturally contains caffeine, so both work as an evening option without caffeine.
Maca has a dry, slightly gritty mouthfeel that softens once it has had a minute to hydrate in warm liquid. Ashwagandha feels heavier and more resinous on the tongue, which is part of why people reach for a stronger-flavoured base to carry it.
Origin and processing tell you more about quality than marketing claims do. Peru-grown maca and India-grown ashwagandha both come from regions with centuries of cultivation experience, and a reputable supplier will tell you exactly where a batch was grown and how it was dried and milled, rather than leaving it to a vague "ethically sourced" label.
Some concerns have been raised about maca grown outside Peru, including reports of less consistent root shape and unclear growing standards; whole maca root and seed exports from Peru have also been restricted by law since 2003, aimed at protecting the country's biodiversity and encouraging local processing. We check growing region and processing method before we list a root powder, because both affect flavour and how finely it dissolves.
For ashwagandha, whole root powder and standardized extract capsules are different products with very different potency; dosing advice written for a capsule does not carry over to a spoonful of loose powder.
A few groups should check with a healthcare professional before using either root: anyone who is pregnant or breastfeeding, since ashwagandha is traditionally avoided in pregnancy and maca also has limited safety data in this group; and anyone with an existing medical condition, since published case reports have linked ashwagandha supplements to adverse reactions in a small number of individuals.
Anyone on regular medication of any kind should ask their doctor first, since neither root has been studied for interactions as thoroughly as conventional drugs.
To recap the maca or ashwagandha question: maca suits a daily, morning-leaning routine with a friendlier taste; ashwagandha suits an evening routine with a flavour that needs a bit of help. Start with whichever fits your schedule, use a small measure, and check with a doctor first if you take medication or fall into one of the groups above.
Wouter Gryson is the founder of Valley of Tea. He has imported, tasted and sold single-origin teas, herbs and spices for more than 15 years, working directly with growers around the world.
Comments will be approved before showing up.

November 20, 2026 3 min read
Learn to make rooibos iced tea two ways: hot-brewed over ice in 15 minutes, or a smoother overnight cold brew, plus flavour additions and storage tips.

November 20, 2026 8 min read
Learn how to organize your spice cabinet with a practical system that keeps every jar findable and fresh. Temperature, layout, and audit tips included.

November 20, 2026 4 min read
Compare oolong and black tea. Learn about oxidation, flavor profiles, caffeine levels, and which suits your tea preference.
Sign up to get the latest on sales, new releases and more …
Get our free brewing guide: the right water, heat and timing for every tea we sell. You will also hear it first when new harvests arrive.
No spam. Unsubscribe any time.
The guide is on its way.